Trust, Wills and Probate

Court Rejects Unprovable Claim of Property Gift

Arguments over the division of estates are unfortunately common where the value of the assets they contain is substantial, especially if family relationships are fractious. In such circumstances, the distribution of an estate can be delayed by legal wrangling and relationships can sour further. However, a professionally drafted will is the best way there is to ensure that your assets pass to whomsoever you wish to receive them and that challenges by aggrieved people who think they have been unfairly left out of the reckoning are unsuccessful.

In addition, it is always sensible to make sure that any agreements made between family members (e.g. loans) are properly documented, so that misunderstandings cannot lead to disputes.

A recent case shows the sorts of issues that can arise. It involved a farming family, an industry in which similar disagreements are legion. Unusually, the dispute arose before the death of the farm owner. The High Court rejected claims that he had given a £2.5 million cottage to his eldest son and daughter-in-law or that he had promised to leave it to them in his will.

The son argued that the cottage was his just reward for having worked hard and for low pay in the family farming and property development business for 20 years. He and his wife had lived in the property throughout that time, bringing up their children there, and claimed to have spent about £700,000 on improving it.

In rejecting the couple's claim, however, the Court found no evidence that the farmer had given the cottage to them when they became engaged to be married. He had also given them no binding assurance that they would inherit the property. The son had been paid for his work in the family business, from which he stood to benefit in the long term, and had no moral or legal entitlement to the cottage.

The son had knowingly taken a risk when he invested in improving a property that did not belong to him and had never had more than an unenforceable expectation that he would inherit the property on his father's death. The farmer had not acted unconscionably and the Court noted that the possibility remained open that he would in due course choose to leave the cottage to his son and daughter-in-law.


Return to Lists

News

Assets of Elderly Are Target of Wrongdoers

Sun, 14 May 2017

Accountant Forged Mother's $50 Million Will

Mon, 01 May 2017

Probate Charges Increase Likely to Be Delayed

Tue, 25 Apr 2017

Problems for Family Unaddressed as People Still Shun Wills

Wed, 12 Apr 2017

Solicitor Evidence Crucial in Proving Will Valid

Thu, 30 Mar 2017

Massive Increases in Probate Charges on Large Estates on the Way

Fri, 17 Mar 2017

Supreme Court Overturns Daughter's Will Claim Award

Thu, 16 Mar 2017

Attorney Who Forged Will to Accelerate Inheritance Given Jail Term

Mon, 13 Mar 2017

Changes in Trustees - Who Appoints New Trustees?

Fri, 24 Feb 2017

Court Rejects Unprovable Claim of Property Gift

Wed, 08 Feb 2017

Deals

18/04/2017 Kerman & Co advises MySQUAR on oversubscribed placing of £2M
05/04/2017 Kerman & Co’s Corporate & Capital Markets Team advised AIM-quoted client LGO Energy plc in connection with a fundraising of £2.5 million.
16/02/2017 Emmerson Plc lists on the London Stock Exchange Main Market
More >

Contact us

Head Office   Dublin Office

Kerman & Co. LLP
200 Strand,
London,
WC2R 1DJ

Tel: 020 7539 7272
Fax: 020 7240 5780
DX: 99 Chancery Lane
[email protected]

 

Kerman & Co. Solicitors,
Fitzwilliam Hall,
Fitzwilliam Place,
Dublin D02 T292

Tel: 01 9011 115
Fax: 01 6694 798
DX: 99 Dublin
[email protected]